The Witch's Tale. I base that solely on the opening and Old Nancy's narration, which really sets a tone for me and "feels" OTR in a way some shows just don't to me. (It is hard to explain better than that.) Based on the content, shows like Witch's Tale, Haunting Hour, Mysterious Traveler, etc, all seem pretty much the same to me. (And as for The Shadow, my favorite OTR, I never pigeon hole it into horror, though you can rightly put it there, along with detective, mystery, crime, suspense, super hero, etc.) And lastly, I am not nearly the Arch Obler fan that so many people here and in general seem to be.